Top 10 Blue Nile Engagement Rings + Money-Saving Advice

Why choose a Blue Nile ring?

It’s no secret: we at JewelryTalk LOVE Blue Nile jewelry. From exceptional products to top-notch customer service, Blue Nile is a favorite among shoppers, and their popularity is only growing. However, their massive inventory can make it difficult to find a ring you may like, and it’s easy to get lost in the sea of options!🐬 So, we’ve put together a list of 10 incredible Blue Nile engagement rings where you can start your search and learn more about what makes these styles so popular.

Let’s go over:

  • Our top 10 Blue Nile engagement rings
  • Reasons to shop Blue Nile
  • How to save money on Blue Nile jewelry
Top Blue Nile Engagement Rings

Reviews of the top 10 Blue Nile engagement rings

In all honesty, Blue Nile’s entire inventory is lovely. There’s a setting for everyone, and each piece is unique and made with high-quality materials. However, these 10 Blue Nile rings shine above the rest, and we’ve included their rating (out of 5 stars) from real customer reviews just to prove it.💪🏻 As a note, we’ve added a round brilliant, Blue Nile diamond to these settings so you can see what they look like with a simple diamond shape.

Six–Prong Solitaire Setting

There’s nothing quite as bridal as a classic solitaire, and Blue Nile’s six-prong variation is an impressive start to this list. In solitaire settings, diamonds exhibit uninterrupted sparkle🌟 due to the way the stone is held above the metal setting with minimal light blockage. The soft edges of this particular design’s band also give it a little bit of personality that you don’t always find in solitaire styles.

Six-prong styles are trendy and provide additional security for your diamond, and this ring averages a 4.8/5 stars on Blue Nile’s website. However, if you’re more interested in a classic four-prong style, this equally lovely petite solitaire may suit your needs!

Petite Twist Diamond Engagement Ring

We’ve been seeing more twisted band settings as time goes on, and we’re absolutely in love with this delicate yet sparkly design. This petite twisted band solitaire features two thinner bands that intertwine, one that is plain metal and another that offers additional brilliance via plenty of accent stones.😻 It’s a modern twist on the traditional solitaire setting, and it boasts a rating of 4.9 stars!

Reviews mention that this is a stunning setting for the price, so it’s budget-friendly without looking cheap or gaudy. Customers describe the design as feminine and unique, and there’s even a matching wedding band you can purchase to take the guesswork out of trying to fit a band against that twisted shank.

Heiress Halo Diamond Setting

No ring list is complete without a glistening halo setting, and the Heiress Halo Diamond Engagement Ring is a wonderful choice if you’re shopping with Blue Nile. The design comes from Blue Nile Studio, one of the company’s designer collections that produces decadent settings designed with a focus on creativity and sparkle.

The halo and band glitter with diamonds, while the subtle double prongs offer protection and security for your center stone. Available in rose and yellow gold as well as platinum, this halo setting is beautiful in every color, and it has a staggering 5/5 stars from happy customers.

If you love both halo settings and twisted shanks, you may want to consider this twisted halo diamond ring instead. A unique “twist” on our last two highlighted styles, it combines an intricate twisted band with a deep set halo to provide ample brilliance, fire, and scintillation.👏🏻

Pear-Shaped Sapphire Side-Stone Ring

Splashes of color are a fun way to add personality to your ring, and sapphires are a popular choice when it comes to engagement rings. This classic pear-shaped sapphire ring has a center diamond flanked by two pear-shaped sapphires for a stately piece that averages 4.8 stars in its reviews.

We also love the slightly pinched band that’s great for hands and fingers of all sizes! What’s more, those corner prongs on the sapphires will keep the delicate tips of the gemstones safe for many years to come. Reviews from customers mention the ring’s “undeniable quality” and how they receive compliments on its eye-catching design.

Hidden Sapphire and Diamond Engagement Ring

Speaking of sapphires, we love when designers hide a subtle amount of color on an engagement ring, such as this hidden sapphire setting. The center stone and sizeable accent diamonds are stunning on their own, but it’s the side profile of this ring that really brings it all together. When viewed from the side, you’ll notice rows of sapphires fitted along smooth metalwork for a hint of blue sparkle!

It’s no surprise this ring averages 4.9 stars from Blue Nile customers. They seem positively smitten with this design, mentioning how “blown away” they are by the setting’s “perfection” and “elegance”, and many describe its price point as a great value for the product quality you receive.😚

Tapered Baguette Side-Stone Setting

Sometimes a ring needs a little more bling than just a center stone, and this setting with tapered baguette side stones seems to do the trick for many Blue Nile customers. The pinched band and tapered silhouette of the side stones draw attention inward to the center diamond, and the mirrorlike glow of the baguettes enhances the gem’s sparkle without detracting from its beauty.

With a solid 4.7 stars, this ring has some extremely happy wearers! Reviews mention the “stunning” setting, “amazing quality”, and this ring being the “best choice” they ever made.

Hand-Engraved Solitaire Ring

You can always add milgrain, filigree, and other intricate metalwork to a ring’s band to jazz up your setting without adding more diamonds. This hand-engraved solitaire engagement ring is absolutely beautiful, with a delicate scrollwork motif throughout the band to bring attention to the center stone while maintaining that “plain metal band” appeal.

Customers love the detailed yet unassuming nature of this setting, and the ring has an average of 4.9 stars from multiple positive reviews. This ring also comes at a very affordable price point due to the absence of accent diamonds, meaning you can spend more on a brilliant, high-quality center diamond.😊

Petite Micropavé Engagement Ring

For wearers who prefer delicate sparkle, we have this petite micropavé engagement ring that looks as good in rose and yellow gold as it does in classic platinum and white gold! The tiny diamonds along the band create a thin silhouette that adds a bit of brilliance while still allowing the main diamond to take center stage.

Customers describe this stunning setting as “awesome”, a “beautiful ring”, and “even lovelier in person” if you can believe it! We recommend taking a look at the reviews, as there are some unique takes on this setting with different diamond shapes, setting colors, etc. that really show how dynamic this piece is.

Blue Nile Studio Empress Diamond Ring

The chosen ring style of Beyoncé herself, split shank settings are a modern, stylish take on traditional pavé bands. This gorgeous ring from Blue Nile Studio just oozes luxury, and the pinched style of the shanks is ideal for creating a slim silhouette on all hand and finger sizes. As a note, a wedding band won’t sit flush against a split shank setting. But, if that doesn't bother you, there are an unlimited number of wedding bands that would look striking with this engagement ring design.

This is another ring with an unbelievable 5/5 stars, and customers have styled this ring in surprising ways. They describe the band as “superb”, and it’s amazing to see how different diamond shapes completely transform this ring into something deeply personal and special.🤩

East-West Illusion Setting

It’s crazy how designers can change the overall aesthetic of a simple solitaire just by changing the orientation of the diamond or prongs. You can see the effect in this ZAC POSEN east-west solitaire, which has four prongs in the compass rose formation rather than at the traditional four corners alignment. Additionally, the band swirls around the stone like a bypass setting, providing a completely unique look that is nothing like a standard solitaire.

Customers have nothing but nice things to say about this faux bypass solitaire! It draws the attention of passersby while offering comfort and simplicity in its design, and it’s a perfect choice for brides who want a little decadence without overdoing it.

Other engagement ring settings by Blue Nile

Popular engagement ring picks often reflect the fashion trends, such as preferred diamond shapes, metal colors, setting styles, and more. However, unique examples of each setting above can be found all over Blue Nile’s website. We’ve collected some of our favorites below based on their setting, but feel free to peruse the Unique engagement rings filter if you want more options!


Halos are already a popular ring style, but adding a halo that uses mixed metals or colored gemstones can really take your design up a notch. You could always opt for a hidden halo for a fun twist on the traditional style as well, or try a different shape like this kite halo. And we can’t forget the luxurious double halo, which was made for wearers who like to feel as though they’re dripping with diamonds.

Twisted Shanks

We showed you a classic twisted shank design above, but there are several ways to enhance this already unique style. Rose gold adds a feminine, romantic touch to this particular setting, and additional accent stones can really amp up the sparkle. Combining setting styles is always an option too, and this halo design with sapphires and a twisted shank looks positively divine.


If you want to add some personality to your solitaire but are turned off by typical designs with accent stones, try playing with the shape and placement of smaller diamonds to bring a piece to life. The marquise and round side stones on this ring bring a whole new perspective to the piece, and it looks completely different than this cathedral solitaire with a ribbon of diamonds that hug the center stone. We also love this classy emerald-cut solitaire that features equally glowy accent stones in the same shape!

Designer rings

You may also want to take a look at Blue Nile’s premier collection of designer rings, as each one is more unique than the last. Similar to other rings on the website, you can start with a diamond or a setting and build the ring of your dreams.🌌

Blue Nile partners with creative designers like Zac Posen and Bella Vaughan to bring you stunning engagement rings that, while still affordable, look like they cost a pretty penny!🥳

In addition, Blue Nile also has their own lines of designer pieces to purchase. The Gallery Collection and Blue Nile Studio pieces are equally gorgeous and elegant, giving you a chance to find a ring among the many settings imagined by Blue Nile designers themselves.

Why shop for your engagement ring at Blue Nile?

So we’ve already shown you 10 glittering reasons why you should shop at Blue Nile, but what about the company itself? What does Blue Nile offer customers that sets them apart from other online diamond retailers? It turns out, there’s plenty to love about Blue Nile, but here’s a roundup of all the reasons you should give this retailer a try:

  • Blue Nile has almost 25 years of business experience and a commitment to customer-first policies that include transparency throughout the diamond buying process, conflict-free diamond sourcing, and more.
  • Their inventory includes over 150,000 loose stones as well as colored gemstones and lab-created diamonds. There’s also a healthy collection of bracelets, earrings, and necklaces for other special occasions throughout the year.
  • The website has 360° images and videos for most diamonds so you can get up close and personal with each stone or setting.
  • Blue Nile’s extensive customer service offerings include 30-day hassle-free returns, virtual appointments, lifetime manufacturer’s warranties, free shipping within the U.S., price match guarantee, complimentary ring sizing within the first year of purchase, and more!
  • Once you’ve made a purchase, Blue Nile protects your investment with complimentary cleanings, repairs, etc. so your ring will always be in tip-top shape.
  • Many of the engagement ring styles in their inventory have matching wedding bands available that you can purchase to take the guesswork out of finding a suitable match.🤗
  • Need help? Blue Nile offers 24/7 access to non-commissioned diamond professionals via phone, email, or chat.

Tips to save money on your Blue Nile engagement ring

Buying an engagement ring can break the bank in some situations! Luckily, Blue Nile gives customers plenty of ways to save money while still purchasing the ring you want and not just the ring you can afford. Here are a few ways to save money when shopping for a Blue Nile diamond ring:

Choose your Blue Nile engagement ring’s features carefully

Everything from metal color to diamond shape to the 4Cs of your chosen stone can impact price. As such, there are many ways to shave a few dollars off of the cost of your completed ring.

When it comes to the metal for your setting, choosing gold over platinum can save you a few hundred dollars! White gold is nearly as bright as platinum for a fraction of the cost, and rose and yellow gold are perfect options for brides who prefer warm tones. Make sure you take a look at your significant other’s daily jewelry to get a feel for which metal would best suit her tastes.

The shape of your diamond can also impact price: round brilliant is the most popular diamond shape, and therefore it is the most expensive. Other shapes that have seen an increase in price as tastes have changed over the last decade include marquise, oval, and heart, as these silhouettes are very popular. However, opting for emerald, Asscher, trillion, princess, cushion, and other beautiful shapes can help you save money overall.

Finally, the 4Cs are the most important features of a diamond, but they also dictate each stone’s price. To help you in your journey, we’ve actually created a guide to the 4Cs of diamonds, and you can find our helpful tips and tricks for finding a quality diamond for less in the guide.

Try a lab-grown diamond

Natural diamonds are beautiful little slices of the earth itself, but did you know experts can make exact copies in a lab? Lab-grown diamonds are a great alternative to natural gems if you’re trying to be conscious about your budget, diamond mining ethics, and/or the environment, as these stones require less work and leave very little waste behind.

It’s hard to believe, but lab-grown diamonds actually cost 30-50% less than natural stones! That means you can buy a diamond that’s practically double the size of a similar quality natural stone for the same price. For example, just take a look at Blue Nile’s Lightbox collection: these gorgeous lab-grown diamonds are indistinguishable from natural stones and offer the same sparkle for less.

Diamond price match guarantee

Blue Nile’s Diamond Price Match Guarantee is an amazing benefit that you should take advantage of if possible! While Blue Nile promises prices that are tough to beat, sometimes other retailers offer similar quality diamonds for less. In these cases, Blue Nile will price match your chosen diamond to that of the competitor.

Keep in mind that the diamonds have to be a near match in quality, but otherwise you can easily start a price match today. Simply call 1-888-565-7641 to speak with a diamond consultant who can assist you with your match.

Use the Blue Nile credit card

By signing up for the Blue Nile credit card, you can take advantage of some competitive financing options to purchase your ring. You can pay a little bit each month with no annual fee and enjoy exclusive access to special offers and promotions that aren’t extended to the general public!

There are even a few different ways to pay, including varying APR and special terms to help the payments fit your budget. You can read more about the terms and conditions of the Blue Nile credit card on their website.

Refer a friend

Shoppers who refer a friend can actually receive special benefits! If you help spread the word about Blue Nile, you’ll receive up to $100 in rewards to be used on your next purchase. Just remember: these benefits only apply once they’ve made a purchase.

New customer benefits

If you’ve never shopped at Blue Nile before, you’re in luck: you’ll receive $50 off for signing up as a new customer. All you have to do is provide your contact information—your name and email in most situations—to receive this sweet, first-timer benefit before you shop.

Shop those sales

Attention sale shoppers: Blue Nile offers excellent deals throughout the year that you can take advantage of!🛍️ Whether it’s a major holiday or just a flash sale on certain products, Blue Nile often drops prices for customers on a monthly basis. Sometimes, it may be a sterling silver sale, whereas others may actually revolve around engagement and wedding jewelry. In short, there’s something for everyone if you’re vigilant and follow their emails and advertisements.

As we mentioned, Blue Nile does provide some great sales during jewelry buying holidays. You can expect good deals around Christmas, Mother’s Day, Memorial Day, and Valentine’s Day with other sales peppered throughout the calendar year.

Buying a Blue Nile engagement ring

While Blue Nile is a top choice for gorgeous engagement rings, this retail giant sells plenty of other quality jewelry as well! Whether you need a wedding band that matches your engagement ring or necklaces, earrings, and bracelets for all occasions, Blue Nile carries diamond and colored gemstone pieces that are sure to please. We recommend visiting Blue Nile soon to peruse their collections and find your next piece!

If you want to learn more about Blue Nile and the company’s rise to fame, you can read more here. Or, for diamond buying tips, try our diamond buying guide for a thorough look at how to purchase a quality, 1-carat diamond.

Leave a CommentReport an Error
Leave a Comment▾

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram